Lots of times when we debate about this, tons of CMs pop up. I want only players that could operate as the deepest lying midfielder and wouldn't need other DMs around him to play world class at least a season in that position. The player I excluded and I'm most torn on him is Tardelli. Has he ever played as a pure DM w/o the need of any other player of that type @ him?
10.Zito
Back-to-back World Champion with Brazil doing the dirty work while the technically gifted stars did their magic upfront. Also absolutely dominated club football with Santos aswell.
9.Obdulio Varela
Regarded as one of the greatest half-backs in football history, Varela was a key player for the Penarol generation wich dominated Uruguayan football. He is also regarded as one of the greatest captains ever for the leadership displayed in Uruguay's World Cup tryumph in 1950.
8.Claude Makélélé
Quite possibly the greatest "destroyer" in football history since the role itself has been coined "The Makelele role". The engine of the star-stacked Galactico generation, he was universally acknowledged by all his team-mates as the most important player.
7.Edgar Davids
The "lungs" of both Ajax and Juve while he played for them in highly succesful periods. One of the most tireless players of all time.
6.Patrick Vieira
The midfield lynchpin for both the "Invincibles" Arsenal and the EURO winning France.
5.Roy Keane
Greatest defensive midfielder in British football history and one of the best Man. Utd. players ever.
4.Xabi Alonso
A destroyer and a deep-lying playmaker rolled into one, Alonso has been a key player in any team he has ever played. World class across 3 of the best leagues of modern era in 4 different team big and small and also enjoyed great succes with the National team.(amongst his less important achievements is dismantling Cambiasso in a CAX)
3.Fernando Redondo
Arguably the greatest defensive midfielder of modern era. In 2016 he was included in the "Argentine National Team of All Time" by the Argentine Football Association, and in 2017 was picked in the "All-time Real Madrid Team" by Spanish newspaper Marca. He was also named Player of the Season by the Olympic Comitee in 2000.
2.Luis Monti
Monti is generally ranked as the greatest Argentinean DM of all time and also the best center-half ever. He was the backbone of the Juve generation who conquered 4 consecutive Serie A titles. With Argentina he won the Copa America, finished runner-up for the Olympics and also at the inaugural World Cup. His greatest achievement is winning the World Cup with Italy.
1.Frank Rijkaard
Easly better than anyone prior to him in this list.
0.Lothar Matthaus
Hands down the best DMC/MC in football history, but I don't want to encourage peeps mentioning players as offensive as Matthaus so consider him out of the ranking.
Do you guys agree with my ranking? If not, let me see your own top 10s.
10.Zito

Back-to-back World Champion with Brazil doing the dirty work while the technically gifted stars did their magic upfront. Also absolutely dominated club football with Santos aswell.
9.Obdulio Varela

Regarded as one of the greatest half-backs in football history, Varela was a key player for the Penarol generation wich dominated Uruguayan football. He is also regarded as one of the greatest captains ever for the leadership displayed in Uruguay's World Cup tryumph in 1950.
8.Claude Makélélé

Quite possibly the greatest "destroyer" in football history since the role itself has been coined "The Makelele role". The engine of the star-stacked Galactico generation, he was universally acknowledged by all his team-mates as the most important player.
7.Edgar Davids

The "lungs" of both Ajax and Juve while he played for them in highly succesful periods. One of the most tireless players of all time.
6.Patrick Vieira

The midfield lynchpin for both the "Invincibles" Arsenal and the EURO winning France.
5.Roy Keane

Greatest defensive midfielder in British football history and one of the best Man. Utd. players ever.
4.Xabi Alonso

A destroyer and a deep-lying playmaker rolled into one, Alonso has been a key player in any team he has ever played. World class across 3 of the best leagues of modern era in 4 different team big and small and also enjoyed great succes with the National team.(amongst his less important achievements is dismantling Cambiasso in a CAX)
3.Fernando Redondo

Arguably the greatest defensive midfielder of modern era. In 2016 he was included in the "Argentine National Team of All Time" by the Argentine Football Association, and in 2017 was picked in the "All-time Real Madrid Team" by Spanish newspaper Marca. He was also named Player of the Season by the Olympic Comitee in 2000.
2.Luis Monti

Monti is generally ranked as the greatest Argentinean DM of all time and also the best center-half ever. He was the backbone of the Juve generation who conquered 4 consecutive Serie A titles. With Argentina he won the Copa America, finished runner-up for the Olympics and also at the inaugural World Cup. His greatest achievement is winning the World Cup with Italy.
1.Frank Rijkaard

Easly better than anyone prior to him in this list.
0.Lothar Matthaus

Hands down the best DMC/MC in football history, but I don't want to encourage peeps mentioning players as offensive as Matthaus so consider him out of the ranking.
Do you guys agree with my ranking? If not, let me see your own top 10s.