Xtratime Community banner

Medel/Vidal/Valdívia: The best midfield partnership since Makelele/Vieira/Zidane ???

5.9K views 112 replies 26 participants last post by  645  
#1 ·
Chile will top their group, no doubt!
Chile will at least reach the semis, for sure!

Their midfield is extremely SOLID!
It reminds me so much of France’s 2006 superb midfield trio of:

Makelele------------Vieira
------------Zidane-:proud:--------


Medel is just as good as Makelele but better with the ball.
Vidal is the best Box-to-box midfielder the world has seen since Matthaus :proud:!
And Valdivia is one of the last true great #10’s!

They are better than Argentina and Uruguay!
WC FINAL prediction:
Brazil v Chile

What say you?
Your thoughts…your thoughts…
 
#12 ·
very unbalanced midfield, IMHO.
There's no true destroyer, there's no true box to box midfielder!
Their game relies on possession and short passes!

the trio of Velasquez, Cueto, and Cubillas were better!
 
#6 ·
Medel is far from "just as good as Makelele". Not even close. Far from a bad player, but also pretty overrated. There are dozens of players like him.

Vidal is fantastic. Different to Vieira for sure, but a fantastic player in his own right.

Valdivia is another great player, who could have had an extraordinary career because very few players have his supreme talent, but his lack of discipline has let him down. In any case, he and Zidane in the same sentence is pretty crazy.

Also, Aranguiz and Mati Fernandez might play too, no? I imagine Sanchez, Beausejour and Vargas will be the attackers?
 
#13 ·
Medel and Makelele are very similar. One defends better and the other attacks better. Medel is more complete though!

Vidal > Vieira
and Valdivia is the most underrated footballer since Cueto!
What a stud he is!

Yes Zidane is slightly better but not by much! (in terms of pure talent).
 
#16 ·
He was there on a loan. In addition, he didn't get along with the coach. He refused to learn any of the 4 official languages! The swiss league was below his standards. He's not a fan of swiss cheese or swiss shoes!
 
#19 ·
[tub]7ieS4Eem9Io[/tub]
He's the S. American Edgar Davids but better defensively!
Look at him owning xavi, iniesta, and busquets all at once!
 
#20 ·
[tub]7YqVg7QTdvs[/tub]
Makelele was too limited, no wonder Florentino showed him the door!
 
#21 ·
everyone talks about Platini and Zidane owning Brazil…
but take a look at this guy:

[tub]jDgvQoc5pSs[/tub]
:proud:
 
#23 ·
Zidane was a lot better in every . single . aspect of the game.

I really rate Valdivia a lot, but that comparison is ban worthy.
 
#27 ·
Zidane was superb but valdivia is more of a threat!
He can pass like zidane and charge forward like a maradona or zico!
 
#32 ·
Medel, vidal, valdivia
seriously this midfield is scary!

Medel > makelele
vidal > viera
valdivia < zidane

that's still 2 out of 3!

but how could I forget about this midfield:
Redondo, simeone, maradona!!!!
 
#39 · (Edited)
Ze you do not opine because you are a follower of Corintians and hates to Valdivia.

The opinions of this group of neophytes not interest me, I'll take the opinion of experts.

-Claudio Borghi (World champions with Argentina 1986) said:
"Valdivia is a marvel to watch, after of Diego (Maradona) is the best I saw"
source:
http://www.elmostrador.cl/pais/2012/06/08/futbol-borghi-admite-que-varios-castigados-estan-humanamente-en-condiciones-de-regresar-2/
http://www.soychile.cl/Santiago/Deportes/2012/06/08/97021/Borghi-La-gente-cree-que-todo-lo-bueno-es-gracias-a-Bielsa-y-todo-lo-malo-gracias-a-mi.aspx

-Pelé said
"Right now, Valdivia in Brazil is the best player all... is the star of Brazil"[10][11][12]
Source:
min 0:55-1:00
RgunsJbUYDw

-Carlos Valderrama said:
"I think it's one of the great players we have in world football"
Source
http://www.emol.com/noticias/deportes/2008/04/14/300398/carlos-valderrama-jorge-valdivia-es-uno-de-los-mejores-jugadores-del-mundo.html

—The Argentine Jorge Sampaoli, current manager of Chile before 2014 FIFA World Cup said:
"Jorge is an irreplaceable talent for us... Right now, he’s key to the kind of football that we play, because he’s a class apart – like [Lionel] Messi for Argentina, [Cristiano] Ronaldo for Portugal and [Franck] Ribery for France. We need him at his best."
Source FIFA.COM:
http://www.fifa.com/worldcup/news/y=2013/m=12/news=sampaoli-chile-aren-world-cup-candidates-2249607.html

(They compare to Valdivia with Maradona, Rivery, C. Ronaldo, Messi, Riquelme, Valderrama.)