Well, this is a very good post. One of the best I have read since I joined the forum. Very pleasant to read too :thumbsup:
Taking it as the base, I will take the liberty to add a few comments, to humbly (it would not be easy for me to describe to this extent even teams of current times..) add a few branches to the tree, so to say.
- I understand Juventus wanted Maradona from Barcelona as well, but in the end Napoli offered more money (Platini and co. plus Maradona... that surely could have been interesting). In fact, Maradona went to Napoli for a world record transfer fee being the only player that ever broke the record twice.
- The first season (84-85), the team was a disaster (Maradona's own words). Though they improved in comparison to the previous season when they were close to relegation, they were still a mid-of-the-table team, like Lobo said. Individually however, and like El Lobo also points out, Maradona was in superlative level. So much so that he had already then started to overshadow Platini, the 1985 winner of Ballon d'Or.
- The regional divide point you make is perhaps true, but it also had quite a negative charge against Diego, no? Became the focal point of the hate, the one they wanted to shut up. Maybe he actually used that in his favor, actually.. For motivation
- For the 85-86 season, Giordano matched up well with Maradona and all, but it was also notable Bagni's season, stepping up and becoming the midfield rock of the team. Very solid season. He even started scoring again.
- The 86-87 doblete season, was the defense thaaaat much more solid than the previous year? It conceded as many goals. De Napoli turned out to be a great signing indeed and Carnevale, I dunno. I just never thought much of him. He did score his few goals though.
About not having a real challenger... I think I know what you mean. It is true that Juve was not what had been and Milan was not yet what it would be (neither Gullit nor Van Basten were there yet, Ze). Then again, this aging Juve did better in Serie A than the 84-85 Juve and Ze goes on and on about Junior's 2nd place with Torino that year ... IMO it is also true that the way you Lobo describe most of the Napoli players of the time could be used to describe a bunch of other players in other teams. Looking at some of the top teams of the time (Roma, Juventus, Milan, Sampdoria, Inter or even Verona), they had players in their squads of similar or superior caliber. Take away Diego, leave him in Barcelona, and Napoli, with all the signings bar that of Maradona, is arguably not even on par with many of them. Throw Diego in and he leads them to the league title. Pure speculation. Just my opinion.
- For the 87-88 season, was Careca clicking right away, or did he have a bit of a hard time adapting? He did have a prolific season (in Serie A of the time terms), and formed the MaGiCa trio that worked so well despite the bad ending, but I cant help resenting him (more with the heart than with the head, of course) for missing those goals agianst Real Madrid that could have given Diego -and Napoli- the chance (it turned out to be his only shot at it) to win the European Cup.
- The 88-89 season, with as much quality as he contributed to Napoli's midfield, Alemao missed about half the league games. Do you happen to remember/know what was their most used line-up that season in Serie A? I am an Inter fan, but damn, did they have to be so efficient that one season of them all?!:smileani:
- The 89-90 season, how significant you consider Careca's impact to win the title? No doubt he was a great striker, best Brazilian of his generation and so on.. but he scored merely 10 of the almost 60 goals Napoli managed that season and missed 12 out of 34 games..
- The 90-91 season that began and ended so bad... Maradona (thus Napoli) was just not quite the same anymore. What do you think is the reason for his decline? Simply age, injuries catching up, frustration for the WC, drug problems, all the above..?
Cheers.