Xtratime Community banner
1 - 20 of 23 Posts

Haroon

· Registered
Joined
·
11,169 Posts
Discussion starter · #1 ·
This is in the latest edition of 4-4-2 magazine. I'm not much of a reader but I got the magazine as it had a big article on Juve and Serie A tourist guide. Anyways here is what Carra's perfect XI is word by word as it is in the magazine:

Goalkeeper

Neville SOUTHALL [Everton & Wales]

I was an Evertonian as a kid and I stood behind him many times on the terraces so I couldn't look beyond Big Nev for my goalkeeper. He saved Everton so many times over the years and even now he's still probably the best keeper I have ever seen.



Right-Back

Marcos CAFU [AC Milan & Brasil]

It has to be him by virtue of the fact that he has played in three successive World Cup final and that takes some doing. I don't think anyone will ever do that again and to still be going at the age he is now shows just what a good player he is.



Centre-Back

Franco BARESI [AC Milan & Italy]

Baresi bossed simply the best club side I have ever seen - the Milan team of the late - 1980s and early - '90s. They had great attacking players, not least Ruud Gullit and Marco van Basten, but they were based on being sound at the back and Baresi was obviously the one who organised them. Basically he told the rest of them what to do and he was the main man in defence.



Centre-Back

Marcel DESAILLY [Chelsea & France]

I've played against him in the Premiership and he is someone who could raise his game when he wanted to. He loved the big occasions. Whenever we used to play against him at Anfield he used to play so well that, to be honest, it was a case of men against boys.



Left-Back

Paolo MALDINI [AC Milan & Italy]

It's easy to take him for granted but he's a legend in his own lifetime. Obviously Roberto Carlos is also a top player but Maldini is much better defensively - and, like Carlos, he can also get forward and provide an extra attacking option - like he did in the Champions League final!



Right-Midfield

Zinedine ZIDANE [Real Madrid & France]

I would play four in midfield and that would have to include Zidane, the best player of the modern era. I would select him officially on the right but give him a free role because there's no one better for such a job. He seems to have so much time on the ball and there's so much to him - dribbling, creativity, passing, scoring and he's a big lad too, powerful at set-pieces.



Centre-Midfield

Graeme SOUNESS [Liverpool & Scotland]

'Souey' had everything. You don't see many players who can put their foot in and also dictate a game the way he could. It's not just about tackling, it's also about passing too. Obviously Steven Gerrard is a great player and maybe in years to come he can compare to Souness, but I've seen videos of Graeme and he was probably more like Roy Keane and Glenn Hoddle rolled into one.



Centre-Midfield

Roy KEANE [Manchester United & Republic Of Ireland]

And talking of Roy Keane, I'd have him alongside Souey at the heart of midfield. The Man United skipper may be a little short of Souness in the passing department but he has so much drive, he can get forward into the box to score vital goals, and he can also put his foot in. And let's be perfectly honest, the opposition would have trouble imposing their game on Souey and Keane!



Left-Midfield

John BARNES [Liverpool & England]

Barnesey is simply the best player I've ever played with or trained with. It was a real pleasure and privilege to be there with him. He was phenomenal. I don't think I ever saw him give the ball away, in a match or training. He'd be on the left of the midfield, which is of course his natural position - and that's why Zidane's got to go on the right!



Centre-Forward

Marco VAN BASTEN [AC Milan & Holland]

Probably the best striker I've ever seen. He wasn't just a goalscorer: he could hold the ball up superbly and had great skill, which he showed in his goals. He'll always be remembered for hooking a stunning volley into the top corner in the Euro 88 final but at that time, at Milan, he was the main man in the best team in the world.



Centre-Forward

Kenny DALGLISH [Liverpool & Scotland]

Kenny would play just off Van Basten. Liverpool were obviously the most successful team in British football and to me, he was the best player who ever played for Liverpool. He won three European Cups and scored the winner in his first one, against Bruges at Wembley. He was a legend at Liverpool and rightly deserves to be in my Perfect XI. He was a goalscorer but he was equally proficient at setting up chances for others, notably Ian Rush - as Marco would appreciate!



Substitutes

Thierry Henry [Arsenal & France]
Jamie Carragher [Liverpool & England]

What a great player Thierry Henry is - I'd say he's the best player ever to play in the Premiership, probably just ahead of Alan Shearer. And, as it's my team, I'd put myself on the bench as well because I can play in a number of positions - not that it would be easy to get into this team!


-------------------------Southall------------------------------

-----Cafu--------Baresi-----------Desailly----------Maldini------


-----Zidane--------Keane--------Souness---------Barnes-------


-----------------Van Basten-------Dalglish---------------------

Subs:

  • Henry
  • Carragher
 
Jern Lizardhous said:
so if you take out the understandable Scouse bias, Carragher would have MvB and Henry as his front 2, :thumbsup:

daglish is a legend wonderful player ,so why should he dump him on the subs bench for any player ?
 
Good team atleast he's being honest and not put in players who he's only seen 10 minutes of in black and white e.g. Pele, Garrincha etc.

How Henry get's anywhere near the team is baffling though :yuck: Take him off and put Keegan on the bench :thumbsup:
 
Jern Lizardhous said:
because Henry is even more wonderful.
in your opinion ,kenny daglish was great player great manager and a living legend ,henry is your legend so we can agree to disagree.
 
liver bird said:
in your opinion ,kenny daglish was great player great manager and a living legend ,henry is your legend so we can agree to disagree.
I know he was a great player , it's just my opinion :thumbsup:

dunno about manager though, he bought a few good players and then seemed to get out when it got a bit tough.
 
Jern Lizardhous said:
I know he was a great player , it's just my opinion :thumbsup:

dunno about manager though, he bought a few good players and then seemed to get out when it got a bit tough.
its better than staying for too long and getting tainted by it all , the cycle of liverpool's league success was coming to end as was daglish's era ,he left emotionally drained after the hillsborough etc.
 
Jern Lizardhous said:
I know he was a great player , it's just my opinion :thumbsup:
Yeah. and That's just CARRA's OPINION
So you couldn't write he's biased, ok?
I think you're biased to Arsnal. lol
 
Jern Lizardhous said:
well he does have 4 players from Scouse teams in it, perhaps he aint biased then just narrow minded :pp
well he put roy keane in, at the end of the day its his opinion, he put 3 milan players in, but that doesnt mean he's biased. its his opinion. :D
 
well, i always kep an eye on PerfectXI in 4-4-2, and normally people who make those teams prove they either biased or stupid. This is by far the most comprehensive, classy and intelligent choice they ever published. Just read his notes below! Who else would come up with Keano+Hoddle=Suey. Top class, Carra!!!

And Jern, take a walk, pal. :D Dalglish's name on the list meant that we'll be crowned kings of England and Europe. Oh, and it always gave me goosbumps to see our famous #7. Who the f*** is Henry? ;)
 
Discussion starter · #18 ·
I personally think that Carra's starting XI is one heck of a team. It has a very good balance to it and that team in theory wouldn't be easy to beat at all.
 
you can tell carra's team is influenced more by the teams he's watched over his generation than with bias, he has 5 current/ ex-milan players in it, those from hte great milan team, along with great players he's also played with or watched. :D

Carra a future Liverpool Manager :D:D:D:D:D
 
liver bird said:
its better than staying for too long and getting tainted by it all , the cycle of liverpool's league success was coming to end as was daglish's era ,he left emotionally drained after the hillsborough etc.
I don't think we realised how much it took out of him, nor the players:(
 
1 - 20 of 23 Posts