Xtratime Community banner
241 - 260 of 279 Posts
Dribble&Trix said:


1.Also Doc_Rule really twists all the aguments in a very Raul favourable way

When Ronaldo2001 said Ronaldo had proven himself on every level,that was so very true.
Ronaldo has had a constant high level up until he was injured
in all different leagues

Clearly Doc_rule doesn´t appreciate the strikers since they normally isn´t so involved in the total play. I also prefer more complete forward players but I think we all can agree that Ronaldo is among the topstrikers of the world,even stats show this.
1. I'd love to know how I've done anything different in favour of Raul than you have in favour of Ronaldo
2.Two years at top club level is not "proving yourself constantly"
3. I think i've said on a number of occasions that he is one of the best goalscorers in the world, i simple refuse to accept that he is the "best player" in the world.

and as far as them being involved in the build up, that's not what i meant when i said he doesn't run when he doesn't have the ball, I'm talking about when the other team has the ball and instead of trying to win it back, like every other top striker in the world does, he stands around with his hands on his hips.
 
OAnimal said:
I was not looking for excuses for Ronaldo, I only wanted to state he had not much chance to prove himself in CL. Wait until he plays a full season or two in CL, then we'll have more to discuss about this issue. I was trying to say, that in every competition he played (when he was fit), he did very well.
I've said more or less the exact same thing.

We differ on "proving" proving himself", i just don't think that 2 years of, admittedly wonderful, performances in the top leagues in the world is enough proof that he is among the greats(as Kalel said he was)
 
Doc_Rule:
2. Henry, Rvn, Crespo, Shevchenko and Trezeguet are currently better than him in terms of all round game, in terms of goals, Henry, RVN, Beattie, and Makaay are all ahead of him this season.However, fit and on-form, only RVN, Sheva and Henry are in Ronnie's class, but Ronnie isn't fit is he.


Actually at the moment he is very close to these.
Stats can also show this and then we talk goal ratio
Shevchenko and Trezeguet is really not contenders this season
hasn´t performed regularly this season at all.

Ronaldo in 94-98 was in a completely different level than any of these and stats supports that too. At times they can reach this level but not on regular basis.
 
Dribble&Trix said:
Ronaldo showed an INDIVIDUAL level in 94-98 at both club and NT level that Raul still hasn´t arrived at
at least not in my opinion
this is supported by stats too
I wouldn't go that far. I would say that based on Ronaldo's season at Barca, Raul has yet to match it. That is true. However, Ronaldo's other seasons before that, as Doc pointed out are not a fair comparison. Even though the Brazil league and Dutch league are not crappy leagues by any means, it's pretty obvious that a striker such as Ronaldo or Raul will find it a hell of a lot easier to score goals in those leagues then in la Liga or Seria A. Raul in his first season with Madrid scored 19 goals at the age of 18, just in la Liga not including the CL. So, one can argue that based on the fact that the average anual pichichi scores about 27-30 goals. He did fairly well for his first real season at Madrid. If he had played for the Dutch league instead I'm sure his goal count would have been much higher. So, yes Ronaldo had the one or two explosive seasons at Barca which I think we all agree, no player has come close to matching. However, before that time frame it is not a fair comparison and after Barca, he has yet to get back to that form due to injuries and what ever other factors that have hampered his success. So as Doc as stated, it's just a matter of him not being that best player at the moment.
 
Doc_Rule said:
I've said more or less the exact same thing.

We differ on "proving" proving himself", i just don't think that 2 years of, admittedly wonderful, performances in the top leagues in the world is enough proof that he is among the greats(as Kalel said he was)
Well, I would always add his performances with the NT in this context as well. Afterall, most of great players are remembered more for their performances in the NT than in the clubs, right?
 
Dribble&Trix said:
1.I just get tired when Doc_Rules only way to argue for Raul is to put down the performances of Ronaldo

2.Ronaldo showed an INDIVIDUAL level in 94-98 at both club and NT level that Raul still hasn´t arrived at
at least not in my opinion
this is supported by stats too

3.after his injury he hasn´t reached Rauls level yet
Can we agree on this?

4.As I said before
I think they can perhaps become the most perfect match as an attacking duo,time will tell.
1.Again i have not done anything in favour of Raul that people here haven't done in favour of Ronaldo, if you read my posts i have praised him were i felt he was worth praising, just as you have done towards Raul

2.Again the Dutch league is not comparable to LaLiga, so only 96-98 and you are right on an individual level Raul hasn't reach those heights, partly because he's more of a team player and a support player than Ronaldo.

3.This debate started out on who was currently better, you've just said Raul is.What was the point of arguing about it for a week??

Ronaldo at his very best 96-98 was a better individual player than Raul at his best 2001-2003, but Ronaldo was at his best 5 years ago, Raul is playing the best of his career now.

4. Hopefully they will become one of the great pairings, but there's still a lot of work to be done.
 
OAnimal said:
Well, I would always add his performances with the NT in this context as well. Afterall, most of great players are remembered more for their performances in the NT than in the clubs, right?
Not neccessarily true. Cruyff never won a WC with Holland. Di Stefano other than 1 Copa America championship with Argentina and after playing for Colombia and eventually Spain has never really been remembered by his international successes. Even if Spain does not win a WC in the next 10 years, Raul will still be remembered as a legend around the world just as Butragueno is.
 
Mendieta:
"If he had played for the Dutch league instead I'm sure his goal count would have been much higher"

I wouldn´t count on that
but maybe U are right

Maybe U seem to think too highly of La Liga and too little of the Dutch league
especially defensively

Anyway
Both Romario and Ronaldo maintained the same level
of goalscoring
both in Brazil,Holland and Spain
which was great

And Raul has yet to reach that level
 
One from the heart

Actually the performance of Ronaldo between 96-98 and in WC02 is enough for me,that was something out of this world
and I will always remember him for that

And as U say Raul will probably have to get Spain a WC
before he can be mentioned as better than Ronaldo
at least for everyone else than Real fans

Momentarily greatness at the right time is better than being good for many years

Sorry just had to get it out
 
Actually I´ve said that I agree with U
that Ronaldo has some work to do
and only time can tell weather he will be able to really comeback
but I get upset when many RM fans just ignore the things he do
and that he is settling quite well
And one has to take into account that he has been injured for a long time
But U just don´t give him any credit
Real fans will need patience
I don´t like that he is "untouchable" or a god that could be a dangerous status for him
But he is a human and need respect for that
 
Mendieta said:
I could live with that. Di Stefano by many is arguebly the best player there ever was.
Might be, for those who never heard of Pele. ;)
 
Mendieta said:
Not neccessarily true. Cruyff never won a WC with Holland. Di Stefano other than 1 Copa America championship with Argentina and after playing for Colombia and eventually Spain has never really been remembered by his international successes. Even if Spain does not win a WC in the next 10 years, Raul will still be remembered as a legend around the world just as Butragueno is.
Note, that I said most players are remembered for their performances in NT, not all of them. And BTW, Cruyff did great with Holland NT even though he never won a World Cup.
 
You said you'd prefer a golden boot to a championship, same thing.
Nope, at last I didn't mean it this way so once again: a Golden Boot is imo more relevant to judge about an individual quality of a player because a championship is won by the quality of 11 players.

1. But the point is that Kalel and ZeDeFiel both said he is the best "player in the world", they didn't specify striker, thus comparison with Totti, Zidane etc is fair
I'm sure they mean "best player of the word in his position." If I'm talking about a "best player" or compare plaers, I always do this on position. How to rate a keeper compared to striker etc. ? It doesn't work imo.

2. Henry, Rvn, Crespo, Shevchenko and Trezeguet are currently better than him in terms of all round game, in terms of goals, Henry, RVN, Beattie, and Makaay are all ahead of him this season.However, fit and on-form, only RVN, Sheva and Henry are in Ronnie's class, but Ronnie isn't fit is he.
First of all it depends on the definition of to be the "best". I don't know your definition so I can also talk from my point of view:

- Henry: he is "one" of the best today I agree although he wasn't able to lead Arsenal to a final round, but thats not only his fault of course
- RVN: he has never been in Ronaldo's class of a player and will never be there, lacks to much skills, a great scorer though but no way a dancer on ball.
- Crespo: injured
- Sheva: sitting on bench most of the time
- Trezeguet: great goalscorer last season, horrible World Cup and a solid but no outstanding season by now, not that skilled at all.

He didn't prove himself before his injury, well he did but not consistantly, 2 seasons of top class football was all he played, lots of players have had two good seasons.And he hasn't proven himself since either, if he keeps on scoring then at the end of the season, yes he'll have proved something, if he does again next year, he'll have proved himself even. And at 17 he played in Brazil(poor league, not comparible to La Liga, Seria A or EPL) and then he played in the dutch league(again, poor league.
Not consistantly ? He has been "outstanding" in every league he played so far. He has been a Brazilian NT-player in the age of 17 (!), he came to Europe without any clue and ruled a foreign league, at first in Holland then in Spain. But he is not a Dutch or Spanish player, he had to adapt their to a different soccer and a different culture but these disadvantages didn't small his soccer. Thats what I call "class". The Brazilian league isn't a poor league by the way, its the school of the best and most succesful soccer-culture on earth. The place where "jogo bonito" started and became developed. Pelé, Garrincha etc. gave it the name but I guess you know what I'm talking about.

He is improving and hopefully will continue to do so, but once again i will point out to you that this whole thing started from Kalel or Ze De Fiel or JCAMILO or Brazil_forever saying that he was THE BEST PLAYER IN THE WORLD, and this is something he is clearly not.
If they say he is the best player (= striker in this case) in the world its their opinion you have to accept. If you prefer Raul or someone else, fine.
 
Dribble & Trix :

Comparing Ronaldo and Raul isn´t ridiculous
My friend, We can compare anything. Ridiculous was how it was perfomed here.

Weather he would be chosen to Brazil NT or not is just a ridiculous thing to say and makes this discussion impossible

See what I mean ? ;)

Doc_Rule:

The dutch league is not a fair comparison, it's a very poor league and average players have scored 20plus goals a season in that league, hardly reason to say they are great players.
This for example is ridiculous. It is obvious, since Ronaldo keep his level of scoring at SPanish league and Italian that the reason he scored a lot there was not the weekness of the others.
Btw, When Ronaldo played there Ajax became the best team in the world. And Ajax showed up in all levels that he was good because of their qualities, not because of anyone weekness. Btw, before the middle of 90's the spanish league and Dutch league are very similar. Two great teams (Real, Barcelona, Ajax, PSV) overuled the league with a thrid power with occasional show (Feeynoord, Deportivo for example), It was only in the break of the 90's that others teams like Valencia made the competion in spain to tight up.

Ronaldo has had two great seasons(1996-97 with BARCA, and 1997-1998 with Inter), and this season(goalwise it's very good, performance wise it's only average) while playing in top class football, Raul has consistantly delivered for Real since 1995.
You are clearly biased. Raul did not played in the level he play today since 1995, not in a million of years.

JCamilo has called me unfair, possibly, but i saw Ronaldo at his best on a number of occasions,
Yes, I call you unfair because you do not use the same scale to judge both, you constanly lie to try prove a point and you do not even pay attention to whom you are talking at, being agressive turning against everyone for thing YOU do.

Raul has proven himself time and again for Real, he won two titles and a CL before any of the superstars arrived(well Carlos was there but he wasn't a superstar at the time).
Like this. Roberto Carlso arrived at real as starting of Brazil and two times brazilian champion. And besides him there was Ilguiner, Hierro, Panucci, Seedorf, Redondo and Mihatovic, all of them stars. And 3 of them (Panucci, Seedorf, Redondo) superior even to those names real have today.

scoring goals in a WC isn't a sign of greatness
If scoring in WC is not a sign of greatness, what would be ?
Such bull. Look the list of player that scored more than 10 goals in a WC (Muller, Pele, Kcosis, Fontaine, Klismanns, Lato, Ronaldo, Sweller, Cubillas...sorry if I miss anyone). This list is of such selected quality that let clear: To Score more than 10 goals in WC you need to be GREAT.

Ronaldo has scored maybe 5 good goals in WC and the rest have been tap-ins,
So only 3 tap ins. (The TAP IN Falacy. I wonder if San_Siro ever registered this trademark, he would get rich and could travel to watch our league. :D )

no individual, with the sole exception of Maradona in 86
Subject for another debate, Maradona was also just the part of team. No one ever won any soccer competition alone.

In terms of what could have been, Ronaldo could(and IMO would) have become one of the all-time great players,
I am glad you are not who decide who will be remembered. I think that Raul and Ronaldo are going to be remembered as the all-time greaters, Raul probally running high for the "best spanish player ever" (without putting likes of Di Steffano and Puskas here). Ronaldo keep writting his story and seems like he is writting very good ones.

If Ronaldo can consistantly score 25plus a season for Real for the duration of his contract, then he will have proven himself as a consistant performer,
If he keep the average goals/game he have now he will do that in the first year. So why to complain for something that did not happened yet. Opinions about the future are fine, but opinions about the future as the truth are lame.

yeah Ronaldo gets to play against Peru, Bolivia and El Salvador, plus Brazil play like 5 matches a year more han European teams due to the qualification system the South Americans have for WC's
See that is unfair. You either lie to prove your point, you try to use opinions without even seraching for facts and you do not consider the simple fact that spain plays against Austria, Farrow Isle, Macedonia, etc as well. If you are honest, you need to start thinking before writting.
Do you realize that Ronaldo NEVER played a single Qualification game for Brazil ? Yes, never. He was not called in 1993. Brazil did not played the Qualification in 1997 and in 2000/2001 Ronaldo was injuried all long.
And before you forget the system, Remember that besides the Qualification for the WC, they play a similar system for the qualification for the EURO, which there is no similar here in SA.
And before you talk about the Copa America, it have few games, just like the final round of EURO and Ronaldo only played it twice, 97 and 99.
And the 50 games in world turn is bull. Cafu is the player that most played for Brazil in the actual team and just recently achived the 100th games limit. If in such short period Brazil had played that number of games he would have done much more.

Henry, Rvn, Crespo, Shevchenko and Trezeguet are currently better than him in terms of all round game, in terms of goals, Henry, RVN, Beattie, and Makaay are all ahead of him this season.However, fit and on-form, only RVN, Sheva and Henry are in Ronnie's class, but Ronnie isn't fit is he
It is fun how you claim Ronaldo will not achive his full potential because of injuries and you actually do a list with injuried players or those like Shevchenko who have more than a 1 years since a regular playing...
PLus, Drible-trix told you and we have those messages here, he is not behind them, actually way close to all of them but RVN who is showing to be the great scorer in europe today was jardel was able to be.


And at 17 he played in Brazil(poor league, not comparible to La Liga, Seria A or EPL) and then he played in the dutch league(again, poor league.
Bull bigoted opinion. I DOUBT you have ever followed the brazilian league to be able to have a decent opinion about that.
The truth is: The Brazilian league during the 90's was as good as EPL, Serie A dropped level and last years have not been clearly superior to brazilian league and only recently La Liga was in the top, clearly.

He is improving and hopefully will continue to do so, but once again i will point out to you that this whole thing started from Kalel or Ze De Fiel or JCAMILO or Brazil_forever saying that he was THE BEST PLAYER IN THE WORLD, and this is something he is clearly not.
I hate lies I hate people who does not consider the others enough to even know to whom you are talking. I never said that here and this thing started when you posted that work of art about Ronaldo goals against lokomotive where the only thing you did was to diss Ronaldo.

1. I'd love to know how I've done anything different in favour of Raul than you have in favour of Ronaldo
Now you do not even pay attention in the extreme moderate posting of Dribble&Trix....
This is annoying and offensive.
 
You are clearly biased. Raul did not played in the level he play today since 1995, not in a million of years.

That's not entirely true. In Raul's first ever season he only scored 9 goals at the age of 17. However, in the following two seasons when he became a regular he scored 19 in 95/96 and then 21 goals in 96/97. He was already notching goals in the Champions League as well and I'm not even counting assists. He was delivering consistently back then as much as he does now. However, at the same time to say that he is the exact player back then that he is now would imply that the guy hasn't improved or progressed in all this time, which we all know is not true. So, in terms of consistantly delivering for his team , he has pretty much been doing that from the beginning and throughout his career, with the exception of one season that I can recall where he was battling with small nagging injuries and delivered a little less than usual.

Roberto Carlso arrived at real as starting of Brazil and two times brazilian champion. And besides him there was Ilguiner, Hierro, Panucci, Seedorf, Redondo and Mihatovic, all of them stars. And 3 of them (Panucci, Seedorf, Redondo) superior even to those names real have today.

True, Roberto Carlos was already a superstar, but he was still not the complete player he is now. Also even though the Real Madrid of Mihatovic and Suker was very good, to say that Panucci, Seedorf and Redondo are superior even to the names of today is stretching it. Don't get me wrong, Redondo and Seedorf are great players, but how can you say that they are even better than Zidane or Figo? No way. There is no comparison to the offensive power that Madrid has now, only the Madrid of the 1950-60's of Di Stefano can be compared.
 
241 - 260 of 279 Posts