Xtratime Community banner

1 - 12 of 12 Posts

·
Registered
Joined
·
5,101 Posts
Discussion Starter #1
What does everyone think about the State of Origin? I used to love watching Victoria-South Australia matches. They were passionate and exciting, and brought a real sense of pride over the state.

I do not understand why State of Origin football is no longer and why many of the 'higher powers' in the AFL have said that it won't be back.

EJ Whitten would be turning in his grave right now. I remember the 1995 State of Origin match at the MCG, when good old Teddy was doing a lap of honour for the last time before he died. Tens of thousands of Victorians and even the South Australians were clapping and many were crying as it was such an emotional moment.

I think that if the AFL goes back to the drawing board and comes up with a consistant and fair system, then State of Origin could be alive again.

Firstly, they need to make it a competition and not just a one off match between Victoria and South Australia. Try and get everyone involved as this is an Australian game, not just a Victorian one.

Secondly, sort of proper teams not not go changing it every year. (one year all the states participated, then we had the Allies then then just two teams...) Make 6 teams and stick by it. Victoria, South Australia, New South Wales, Western Australia, Queensland and Tasmania. If Tasmania isn't as strong as the others than maybe they can merge with ACT and NT to make an Allied team.

Thirdly, schedule it for the end of the season and not in between the season. The main reason interest died down was because players weren't committed to their state during the year and many big players didn't play.

What does everyone think?
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
4,724 Posts
I am a great fan of State of Origin but Footy is so proffesional these days that players will think of injuries & pay packs instead of State pride. Just think how stuffed would you feel you a 22 year old , 5 clubs are chasing you cause your kicking arse & your contracts up and they are all showing you mega $$$$$$$$ and you play state of origin and bust your knee ???? I would feel sickened to the guts !!!

How would Essendon fans feel if Hird busted his knee playing for the Allies , or Brissy fans if Simon Black playing for WA or Dockers fans if it were Pavlich playing for SA ..... I would tell you things would get pretty ugly amongst the fans & just think what would the clubs think ???
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
5,926 Posts
I love it too, but the injury factor is a point.

Tony Hall did his knee in a state game and was never the same again.

It's a shame because this season each state was basically level in terms of talent and ability.
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
5,101 Posts
Discussion Starter #4
The risk of injury is going to be there in whatever they do. It is the same risk as playing International Rules vs Ireland. And that's not even proper football...
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
5,926 Posts
Yeah Sheva, you've got a point... apparently the bruised knuckle rate was obscene :D
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
4,724 Posts
dyertribe said:
Yeah Sheva, you've got a point... apparently the bruised knuckle rate was obscene :D
DT I am waiting for you to whinge when Carey , McLeod , Burns & Co are injured for round #1 when they have been hurt in Ansett Cup Fixtures !!!! At least its an excuse when you's get pounded in #1 !!!!!!!!
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
5,926 Posts
COUTO 5 said:
DT I am waiting for you to whinge when Carey , McLeod , Burns & Co are injured for round #1 when they have been hurt in Ansett Cup Fixtures !!!! At least its an excuse when you's get pounded in #1 !!!!!!!!
:D

Got my gold membership renewal in front of me... bring it on :fero:
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
4,724 Posts
dyertribe said:
:D

Got my gold membership renewal in front of me... bring it on :fero:
Let me tell you a story !!!!!!!

McManus will kick 8 goals to win us the game in #1 !!!!!!!!

We Will be pumped !!!!!!!!
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
4,724 Posts
COUTO 5 said:
Let me tell you a story !!!!!!!

McManus will kick 8 goals to win us the game in #1 !!!!!!!!

We Will be pumped !!!!!!!!
How will crow eaters react when they get smashed by Freo in #1 !!!!!!
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
4,724 Posts
COUTO 5 said:
How will crow eaters react when they get smashed by Freo in #1 !!!!!!
Pavlich will kick 5 as well as Byron Schammer !!!!!!!!!!!!

Go west Adelaide !!!!
Pavva !!!!!!!
Schammer !!
Modra !!!!!!


West Adeleide Boys love Freo !! I hear you live in West Adeliade DT !!!
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
5,926 Posts
COUTO 5 said:
Pavlich will kick 5 as well as Byron Schammer !!!!!!!!!!!!

Go west Adelaide !!!!
Pavva !!!!!!!
Schammer !!
Modra !!!!!!


West Adeleide Boys love Freo !! I hear you live in West Adeliade DT !!!

Pavlich is from Woodville-West Torrens mate ;) And I live nowhere near the tip that is the west-saeeeeeeeeed!
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
4,724 Posts
dyertribe said:
Pavlich is from Woodville-West Torrens mate ;) And I live nowhere near the tip that is the west-saeeeeeeeeed!
doesnt matter ;)

we'll keep those West Adelaide ( Specailly the Torrens Boy ;) )boys any way:) Dt I know Deep down you HARBOUR a FREO JUmper in yourcloset which you wear at 1 am evry morning when your family are asleep !!!!!!!!!!!
 
1 - 12 of 12 Posts
Top