Xtratime Community banner

1 - 20 of 32 Posts

·
XT's Demi-God
Joined
·
8,662 Posts
Discussion Starter #1
Now that the dust is settled, and we got what we deserved, how do rate the players and managementfor this season. This is not a chance to bash some individuals :lick:, so be objective.

Below is the management & player lists.

Berlusconi 6
Galliani 5
Ancelotti & Tassotti 7

Ambrosini 8
Bonera 7
Brocchi 6
Cafu 6
Dida 4
Emerson 4
Kalac 6
Maldini 7
Nesta 8
Pirlo 7
Pato 8
Inzaghi 7
Kaka 8
Gilardino 6
Ronaldo 5
Gourcuff 5
Gattuso 6
Seedorf 7
Oddo 5
Favalli 4
Jankulvoski 5
Serginho 4
Simic 4
Kaladze 6

24 players leaving aside Ba, Fiori, Darmian, Digao, Aubameyang as none played enough to get votes.

Do consider we reached 2 out of 3 objectives.:rollani:
 

·
The summer poster
Joined
·
397 Posts
Berlusconi 5
Galliani 5
Ancelotti & Tassotti 7

Ambrosini 8
Bonera 7
Brocchi 5
Cafu 5
Dida 3
Emerson 5
Kalac 7
Maldini 7
Nesta 7.5
Pirlo 6
Pato 7
Inzaghi 6
Kaka 6.5
Gilardino 5
Ronaldo 3
Gourcuff 5
Gattuso 6
Seedorf 6
Oddo 5
Favalli 5
Jankulvoski 5
Serginho 4
Simic 4
Kaladze 6.5
 

·
1st Tier Poster
Joined
·
49,978 Posts
Berlusconi 4 - the main culprit. Got us Pato and that must be acnowledged but overall has been stingy on the transfer market for several seasons now.
Galliani 4 - I don't know how much can he influence Berlu to provide funds or if he even wants to. But fact is that he is formally responsible for our transfer market.
Ancelotti & Tassotti 4 - somehow they have avoided very harsh criticism during this season but fact is that we finished 5th with a squad which is at least on par with Juve and Roma on paper. They have to shoulder a lot of responsibility for that, being completely unable to motivate the squad or find new working tactical solutions.

Ambrosini 7
Bonera 6.5
Brocchi 6
Cafu 6
Dida 4.5
Emerson 5
Kalac 7
Maldini 6
Nesta 7.5
Kaladze 6
Pirlo 7
Pato 7.5
Inzaghi 7
Kaka 7
Gilardino 5
Ronaldo N/A
Gourcuff 6
Gattuso 6
Seedorf 7
Oddo 5.5
Favalli lol
Jankulovski 5
Serginho 5.5
Simic N/A
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
494 Posts
Berlusconi 6
Galliani 5
Ancelotti & Tassotti 7

Ambrosini 8
Bonera 7
Brocchi 6
Cafu 5
Dida 4
Emerson 4
Kalac 6
Maldini 7
Nesta 8
Pirlo 6
Pato 8
Inzaghi 7
Kaka 7
Gilardino 5
Ronaldo 5
Gourcuff 5
Gattuso 6
Seedorf 7
Oddo 5
Favalli 4
Jankulvoski 5
Serginho 4
Simic 4
Kaladze 6
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
1,558 Posts
Kalac 6.5
Dida 4.5
Nesta 5.5
Kaladze 5
Favalli 4
Cafu 5
Serginho s.v.
Bonera 5.5
Ambrossini 6.5
Kaka 6.5
Pirlo 6.5
Seedorf 6
Gattuso 4.5
Brocchi 2
Gourcuff 4
Oddo 4.5
Jankulovski 4.5
Emerson 4.5
Ronaldo 6
inzaghi 6.5
Pato 7
Gilardino 0
Paloschi 6.5
Digao 4
Simic 5

Ancelotti 5
Gallani 4.5
Berlusconi 4.5
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
12,028 Posts
Kalac 6.5
Dida 4
Nesta 6 -- He was half a step slower than before this season
Kaladze 5.5
Favalli 4.5
Cafu 6 --- He was always good when he played
Serginho s.v.
Bonera 6
Ambrosini 7 -Our best player this season. The only one who kept the level of the season before
Kaka 6 --- Outside of the derby, not a whole lot there. The only milanista who can blame Kaka is me apparently
Pirlo 6 --- Great in many spurts, tired in others. I hope age/games isn't catching up to him. Needs to work on stamina
Seedorf 6
Gattuso 5 ---- Worst season in our colors, even worse than when he just came in from Rangers
Brocchi 4--- Needs to leave
Gourcuff 3--- A non factor, one good cross
Oddo 2.5--- I would ship him out, he is terrible. Outside of the 2 games with arsenal I have never seen a worse milan wing back outside of n'gotty
Jankulovski 4.5
Emerson 4.5 --- Okay when he played, then lost match fitness and got injured
Ronaldo 5 --- Great when he played... twice.
inzaghi 7-- When fit, amazing
Pato 7 ---- The future, and the best of our present.
Gilardino 2 --- With Oddo, gone while you can still get a few bucks
Paloschi 6.5 --- Great
Digao 3 --- One half decent coppa italia game
Simic 5

Ancelotti 5 --- Not his best season
Gallani 4.5 ---
Berlusconi 6--- Got us Pato, and a gentlememan with the heroes from the previous season [/QUOTE]
 

·
Scudetto
Joined
·
23,383 Posts
Kaka, top scorer and best assist man... Yet he receives such low marks from most of you? Joke.

Best players:

Ambrosini
Kaka
Pato
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
596 Posts
After coming back from injury, Kaka was our best player. I don't think that its a coincidence that Pippo's run of form began when Kaka returned.
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
2,529 Posts
Berlusconi 6
Galliani 5
Ancelotti & Tassotti 6

Ambrosini 7.5
Bonera 6
Brocchi 5.5
Cafu 5.
Dida 4
Emerson 5
Kalac 6.5
Maldini 6.5
Nesta 7.5
Pirlo 6.5
Pato 7.5
Inzaghi 6.5
Kaka 7.0
Gilardino 4.5
Ronaldo 5.5
Gourcuff 5
Gattuso 6
Seedorf 6.5
Oddo 4.5
Favalli 5.5
Jankulvoski 5.5
Serginho 5
Simic 5
Kaladze 6
Paloschi 6.5
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
212 Posts
Berlusconi 2
Galliani 2
Ancelotti & Tassotti 7.5

Ambrosini 8
Bonera 5
Brocchi 3
Cafu 2
Dida 1
Emerson 2
Kalac 8
Maldini 6.5
Nesta 8
Pirlo 6
Pato 5
Inzaghi 7
Kaka 8
Gilardino 3
Ronaldo 3
Gourcuff 3
Gattuso 7.5
Seedorf 8
Oddo 5
Favalli 4.5
Jankulvoski 4
Serginho 3
Simic 3
Kaladze 7.5
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
15,061 Posts
Kalac 6.5 - a suprise, almost a 7,0 considering the expectations
Dida 3,0 - should have a group therapy with S. Deisler. In a few matches he played, he costed us dearly.
Nesta 7,0 - still one of the best CD in the world
Maldini 6,5 - il capitano; hope he wont regret doing it another season. Considering how I felt when Arsenal was supposed to be his last match in Europe, I am still very happy he continues
Kaladze 5.5 - insecure, needs to improve again.
Favalli 4.5 - ex-giocatore
Cafu 6,0 - il pendolino, on his last stop in Italy, smiled and scored. Standing ovations, a 6,0 out of nostalgy.
Serginho s.v. - too many injuries never allowed il concorde to take off like he used to do at May 11th, 2001
Bonera 6,5 - doing better than Oddo as a RB, doing better than Kaladze as a CB; personally good season.
Ambrosini 7,5 - probably our best player this season. Should be a starter at the EURO.
Kaka 6,0 - for his season before the break in spring maybe even 5,5. Afterwards, like in the derby, we saw our real bimbo d'oro again.
Pirlo 6,0 - Needs finally someone to give him a rest during the 2008/2009 campaign. When he missed a match, you could see what he means for our play.
Seedorf 6,0 - shadow and light, will hopefully benefit, as all of our midfielders, from the insertion of new faces in our roster.
Gattuso 5,5 - more shadow than light. Almost earned a 6,0 though for telling Galliani straight into the face what he thinks about.
Brocchi 4,5 - go to fiorentina, go
Gourcuff 4,5 - should have thought about it twice before he sodomized D. Ancelotti
Oddo 4.5 - Should concentrate on improving his hair stylist skills. Non- recognizeable in comparison to his Lazio days.
Jankulovski 5.0 - Injury prone and very inconstant.
Emerson 5,0 - As useless as expected.
Ronaldo s.v. - earns millions to get blown by some 'men'. Pah. Good bye.
inzaghi 7,0 - Pippo come maradonna. If he were just 4 y younger and always fit.
Pato 7,0 - The prophet. Cried after his first goal like a young kid, sometimes makes the wrong decision (shooting, passing, dribbling) like a young teenager (which he is) but very often shows the class of an adult super star. A pallone d'oro in the making, I love the kid.
Gilardino 4,0 - biggest disappointment next to Dida.
Paloschi 6.5 - Balls! And what a debut goal. Want to see more of him.
Digao 4,0 - mah... should spend praying 24/7 to God and thank him for the existance of his brother, esp. at the end of the month when his pay cheque arrives.
Ba s.v. - ci mancherai. :pp
Simic s.v. - good riddance and thanks for #6.

Ancelotti 6,0 - his worst season for Milan so far, but I think he had to deal with insufficient 'material'
Gallani 4.5 - to be blamed for the insufficent material, now it's time for a come back, zio Fester.
Berlusconi 5,0 - dito Zio Fester
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
24,062 Posts
Berlusconi 2: He's got something in his mind since Calciopoli. Put the kaipash (speling) on all deals that involved Juve, especially Ibra and Buffon :googly:
Galliani 5: A loyal servent of Berlu. Too bad not that quality players were available of free the last 3 season!
Ancelotti & Tassotti 8: Despite all the negative results, they had to deal with a handicapped squad!

Ambrosini 9: True spirit of Maldini's hire.
Bonera 7: Loyal, did excellent almost every tie he was called for, never complained.
Brocchi 4: We all know why.
Cafu 6: He is finished. He can play for abou 15 minutes tops.
Dida 2.975: Celtic! Siena & the derby!!
Emerson 3.5: Roma!
Kalac 7.5: Saved our ass from being 8th or something. Thank God Dida got injured.
Maldini 7: From the few games he played, he showed everyone what a wrold class player is.
Nesta 7: We all know why.
Pirlo 6.5: Without this guy, we are dead dull. Even when he is off form, he manages to create. The missed penalty against Atalanat still hurts though.
Pato 7.5: Discovery of the centuary. May he fill the void of MVB :hopeful:
Inzaghi 8: Based on the time where he was fit, i.e. the last 5 games.
Kaka 6.5: Started bad. He needs to fix his knee.
Gilardino 3: Waste of space.
Ronaldo 4: Excelled in one game out of jeoulsy of Pato!
Gourcuff 2: As Manuel said, keep your penis to yourself.
Gattuso 6: The lion was asleep, unhappy, and unbothered.
Seedorf 6.5: As always, inconsistent!
Oddo 4.5: He came with Ronald, he can go with him too.
Favalli 5.5: Limited!
Jankulvoski 5.5: Injury prone!
Serginho s.v. Too bad he couldn't express himself!
Simic 5: He raped Del piero physically. That's good enough :pp
Kaladze 6: Shacky, still good CD when he is focused.
Paloschi 7: Amazing fighting spirit!
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
15,585 Posts
Gourcuff 4,5 - should have thought about it twice before he sodomized D. Ancelotti
:howler: How did I miss this one?
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
24,062 Posts

·
Registered
Joined
·
4,160 Posts
Guys, what´s the deal with Gourcuff and one of Carlos children?

What did he do? and to who?

Seriously :confused:
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
43,403 Posts
Evaluating Silvio makes me wanna either puke or lough ... I see 2s, 4s, 5.5s ... what the hell ... :D:D:D
 
1 - 20 of 32 Posts
Top