[Grinch]

This week Globo's website has presented this question, and I felt it would be interesting to bring the question here. Who was better, Renato Gaucho or Edmundo? Both had great domestic careers but failed in Europe, both were highly controversial but still enjoyed good moments with the NT. Who was the best player among them?

X

 

[JCamilo]

Renato, more versatile, decisive and even stronger.

 

[Liternit]

hard to say, I think its a tie! They were a lot like, specially if you see Gaucho in Gremio and Edmundo in Palmeiras.

 

[Fangio]

..el Loco Doval...in my crusade for the Locos

 

[El Beatle]

Edmundo for me the better player and would have done better in Europe had he had someone elses brain. Strange location and time to see Takayama also

 

[Fabio Manic]

hahahahahahhahahahahhah
do I have to vote??

 

[DarkwingDuck]

Renato Gaucho.. who can make butt-goals and be an big ass-hole

 

[JCamilo]

hahahahahahhahahahahhah
do I have to vote??

Sure, and in the most unbiased way, you will vote for Edmundo, right?