Xtratime Community banner

1 - 20 of 32 Posts

·
Registered
Joined
·
38,223 Posts
Discussion Starter #1
Can you decide on the player of year for each club in the prem? Some you may not have seen much of, but try to make a judgement. I'll start

Arsenal - Henry
Villa - Not entirely sure. I'd probably say Mellberg
Birmingham - Maik Taylor
Blackburn - Dickov
Bolton - Stelios
Charlton - El Karkouri
Chelsea - Terry
Palace - Johnson
Everton - Stubbs
Fulham - Bouba Diop
Liverpool - Carragher
City - Dunne
United - Heinze
Boro - Er....Downing?
Newcastle - Shearer
Norwich - Francis
Portsmouth - Another toughie. stone?
Southampton - Crouch!
Tottenham - Carrick
WBA - Gera

Anyone else wanna try?
 

·
Welcome To Jamrock
Joined
·
9,729 Posts
Arsenal - Henry
Villa - Err...Solano
Birmingham - Pandiani
Blackburn - Pederson!
Bolton - Jaaskalienen or Diouf
Charlton - El Karkouri
Chelsea - Cech
Palace - Johnson
Everton - Err...Cahill
Fulham - Bouba Diop
Liverpool - MELLOR :D
City - Fowler
United - Fletcher
Boro - Jimmy Floyd Hasselbaink
Newcastle - Shearer
Norwich - Bentley...but he got injured :(
Portsmouth - Lua Lua
Southampton - Crouch
Tottenham - No-one they all sucked :D
WBA - Kanuuuuuuuuuuuuuu :pp
 

·
Premium Member
Joined
·
22,104 Posts
Arsenal - Henry
Villa - Solano
Birmingham - Maik Taylor
Blackburn - Dickov
Bolton - Davies
Charlton - El Karkouri
Chelsea - Lampard
Palace - Johnson
Everton - Cahill
Fulham - Bouba Diop
Liverpool - Carragher
City - Dunne
United - Heinze
Boro - Zenden
Newcastle - Shearer
Norwich - Francis
Portsmouth - errrrrrrr Lua Lua?
Southampton - Crouch
Tottenham - Brown
WBA - Gera
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
4,099 Posts
Dejan Stefanovic for us. Lua Lua close second
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
2,255 Posts
Arsenal - Henry
Villa - Mellberg
Birmingham - Taylor
Blackburn - Pedersen
Bolton - Stelios
Charlton - Murphy
Chelsea - Terry
Palace - Johnson
Everton - Cahill
Fulham - Bouba Diop
Liverpool - Carragher
City - Dunne
United - Neville
Boro - Downing
Newcastle - Given
Norwich - Francis
Portsmouth - Stefanovic
Southampton - Crouch
Tottenham - Robinson
WBA - Gera
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
8,152 Posts
Carrick Brown? LOL King has been Spurs best player this season.

You honestly think Carrick has been more valuable than him this season?
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
12,056 Posts
Arsenal - Henry
Villa - Barry
Birmingham - Upson
Blackburn - Pederson
Bolton - Davies
Charlton - Holland
Chelsea - LAMPARD!!!!
Palace - Johnson
Everton - Cahill
Fulham - Bouba Diop
Liverpool - Gerrard
City - SWP
United - Rooney
Boro - Riggott
Newcastle - Shearer
Norwich - Ashton
Portsmouth - Lua Lua
Southampton - Crouch
Tottenham - Robinson/Defoe
WBA - Earnshaw
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
4,099 Posts
Arsenal - Henry
Villa - Solano
Birmingham - Melchiot
Blackburn - Todd
Bolton - Stelios
Charlton - Holland
Chelsea - Makelele
Palace - Johnson
Everton - Cahill
Fulham - Boa Morte
Liverpool - Carragher
City - Shaun Wright-Phillips
United - Heinze
Boro - Boateng
Newcastle - Given
Norwich - Francis
Portsmouth - Stefanovic
Southampton - Crouch
Tottenham - Robinson or Ziegler
WBA - Gera
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
26,731 Posts
Arsenal - Henry
Villa - Hendrie, how could you not mention him?
Birmingham - Heskey
Blackburn - No idea, they all seem equally horrible to me!
Bolton - Diouf and Speed
Charlton - Hreidarsson, their most consistent player.
Chelsea - Cech! but if Robben had played more he'd take the price.
Palace - Johnson, no doubt. Emerson Boyce has also impressed me.
Everton - Gravesen for the first part of the season... after that, Martyn and Weir.
Fulham - Malbranque, by far their best player.
Liverpool - Carragher and Xabi Alonso
City - Wright-Phillips
United - Heinze
Boro - Southgate
Newcastle - Given
Norwich - Francis
Portsmouth - Lua Lua
Southampton - Crouch
Tottenham - King
WBA - Gera
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
26,731 Posts
How about also one for the most dissapointing player?

Arsenal - Vieira
Villa - Hiltzberger (or however it is spelled..)
Birmingham - Yorke
Blackburn - Stead
Bolton - Hard to find one really! Okocha has slowed down considerably though...
Charlton - Jeffers, Rommedahl, Hughes... pretty much everyone they signed this summer.
Chelsea - Kezman, crap.
Palace - Routledge
Everton - Another hard one... Beattie has done fvck all.
Fulham - McBride, crap player.
Liverpool - Baros
City - Fowler
United - Van Nistelrooy or Saha
Boro - Viduka
Newcastle - Ehm... Kluivert, Dyer, Bramble, Carr... the list is rather endless.
Norwich - Huckerby. NOT PL quality.
Portsmouth - Yakubu and Chalkias
Southampton - Beattie before he left. Bernard after he joined.
Tottenham - Keane
WBA - Kanu
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
580 Posts
Arsenal - Henry - he should win both awards this year, he really deserved it

Villa - They're all a bit shit to be honest, how about Mellberg though

Birmingham - Upson, soon to be Pennant

Blackburn - This award should really go to Mark Hughes. Failing that, the award will probably go to Dickov for doing **** all with a lot of heart.

Bolton - Stelios has been their top player in the matches I have seen.

Charlton - Personally I think they have lower quality players than some of the 4 bottom teams. I'd expect this to go to Jerome Thomas though, as no one else has done anything worth of note. Incidentally that leaves Charlton as a club that has not done anything worth of note. They really need some better players.

Chelsea - Arjen Robben. This one needs no explanation.

Palace - Andrew Johnson. How he has 18 goals, despite missing so many sitters a match is completely beyond me though.

Everton - Gravesen's gone. The award might go to Marcus Bent for all the hard work he put in the first half of the season. Cahill is the only attention grabbing player in the team so expect the award to go to him. Or the Wayner, cause he's such a great player. Vaughan's in this one too!

Fulham - Remember Malbranque? I don't. Andy Cole then, he has scored a few.

Liverpool - The winner here is Gerrard, plain and simple. The team plays well as a whole though

City - Wright-Phillips, they don't even need a vote. Dunne my ass (please don't)

Man Utd - Rooney. 3 against Fenerbahce on his debut. They will be talking about him in 5000000 years time!

Boro[Borror] - It will be Steward Downing, I'm not really sure what he's done though other than put a few balls into [roughly] the penalty spot from the left wing

Newcastle - Lee Bowyer. Dyer's looking very lively as well. Shearer will win it, who's asking the question.

Norwich - Ashton has been looking quality, despite not scoring too much. Probably Huckerby though. He really does a lot for the team.

Pompey - Yakubu. Whatever. Does this team have other players worth remembering? O'Neil's not bad either. Incidentally, both have scored against Man Utd in their careers...always the sign of a good player.
Wait, what about that de Zeuuw dude?

Southampton - Crouch has really helped them out. Jamie Redknapp has added a lot of bite to the team, and he looks quite handsome (he has a hot wife)

Tottenham - It shouldn't be Defoe. The guy that said Ziegler was drunk. Should be Ledley King

W.B.A. - Bryan Robson is a ****ing great manager. Gera's pretty good I guess. He'll probably win this one
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
16,663 Posts
Arsenal - Henry
Villa - Solano
Birmingham - dunno Heskey
Blackburn - Dickov
Bolton - Diouf
Charlton - El Karkouri
Chelsea - Lampard
Palace - Johnson
Everton - Cahill
Fulham - Bouba Diop
Liverpool - Carragher (Alonso would of been close if he had been fit all season)
City - Dunne
United - Heinze
Boro - Downing
Newcastle - Shearer
Norwich - Francis
Portsmouth - Stefanovic
Southampton - Crouch
Tottenham - Carrick
WBA - Gera
 

·
Xtratime's Head of Humour 2007
Joined
·
63,337 Posts
AMOROSO! said:
How about also one for the most dissapointing player?

Arsenal - Vieira
you are mad, Vieira has held our midfield together for the last four months while Edu and Gilberto were both out, he had a bad start but has been great the last months.

it would be REYES by a country mile, started off looking a world beater and since then has produced hardly anything for SIX months :wallbang:
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
580 Posts
As to the worst players:

Arsenal - Cygan has been really quite solid looking this season, don't laugh. How about Edu for treating them poorly? Gilberto for being injured? Lehman for being a lemon?

Aston Villa - Carlton "the great white hope [one of many] Cole takes this award with almost no competition!

Brum - What the hell has Heskey done. For that money they could've bought kezman!

Blackburn - Dwight Yorke, although not exactly being shit, has been really quite not so well

Charlton - Bartlett is, without any doubt, the worst player I have ever seen by far. He doesn't deserve to play in an amateur team, and I am being serious. I have seen him play. He is really, really shit.

Chelsea - Mutu has done quite worse than Kezman.

Palace - Lakis has gotten stick before. why i don't know. Don't really think they have any bad players. All of their players have at one game or another put in a brilliant performance.

Everton - richard wright is a ****ing dipshit. beattie has done brilliant though! yeah right. for that money they could've got kezman!

Fulham - Zat "the great white hope" Knight really sucks at football

Liverpool - Dudek might be in reasonably here, although he is a pretty decent keeper. I am keeping him out of the running because twice a year he turns up in a Man Utd shirt, I don't think its fair to have cross-registered players in this category. At least Josemi has never let them down. Can anyone tell me if he's been on holiday with my friend Kleberson lately?

City - are quite shitty at times. Take your pick from any of their geezers

Man Utd - Manchester United has never field a player that dissapoints. For all the countless penalties P. Neville has given away, you will never find an article blaming him. Instead you will find another player (probably his brother) saying it wasn't his fault. At least, he is a Man Utd player and he is dedicated to the cause. Kleberson and Eric from Africa just piss the hell out of me. Because of them we missed out on Robben and Ronaldinho. Robben especially. I ****ing hate you two! **** off out of my sight! Or start playing really good!

Boro - Mark Viduka is an overpaid, overweight bastard. Why Boro thinks he is worth 3.5 million (in what - pies?) is beyond me

Newcastle - Seriously, a lot of their players just suck. Kluivert for one sucks a lot.

Norwich - the **** should i know

Pompey - their stupid greek keeper

Southampton - Prutton's a bright one, innit he

Spurs - Kanoute has been generally shit. So has most of the team

W.B.A. - Now that i look again, their team is just riddle with crap too
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
16,663 Posts
AMOROSO! said:
How about also one for the most dissapointing player?

Arsenal - Vieira
Villa - Hiltzberger (or however it is spelled..)
Birmingham - Yorke
Blackburn - Stead
Bolton - Hard to find one really! Okocha has slowed down considerably though...
Charlton - Jeffers, Rommedahl, Hughes... pretty much everyone they signed this summer.
Chelsea - Kezman, crap.
Palace - Routledge
Everton - Another hard one... Beattie has done fvck all.
Fulham - McBride, crap player.
Liverpool - Baros
City - Fowler
United - Van Nistelrooy or Saha
Boro - Viduka
Newcastle - Ehm... Kluivert, Dyer, Bramble, Carr... the list is rather endless.
Norwich - Huckerby. NOT PL quality.
Portsmouth - Yakubu and Chalkias
Southampton - Beattie before he left. Bernard after he joined.
Tottenham - Keane
WBA - Kanu
ooh, DISSAPOINTING
Arsenal - Reyes
Villa - Hitzlsberger
Birmingham - Yorke
Blackburn - Stead
Bolton - dunno
Charlton - Jeffers (is he even in the team)
Chelsea - Kezman
Palace - Ventola (I know he aint played, but I thought he was gonna be a big player for them, what happened to him?)
Everton - Beattie
Fulham - Johns (i know hes young but expected so much more from him)
Liverpool - Morientes (controversal maybe but whens he gonna start scoring, I can't think of anyone else who had high expectation then did shit. Baros is our top goalscorer so...)
City - Anelka (before he left)
United - RVN
Boro - Viduka
Newcastle - Kluivert
Norwich - Huckerby
Portsmouth - Paddy Berger
Southampton - Beattie (before he left)
Tottenham - Keane
WBA - Kanu
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
16,663 Posts
yaf said:
Brum - What the hell has Heskey done. For that money they
He's their top goalscorer I believe, and has been pretty good in a poor Birmingham season even getting a recall to the NT
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
4,099 Posts
Most disappointing

Arsenal - Vieira
Villa - C Cole
Birmingham - Gronkjaer
Blackburn - De Pedro
Bolton - Okocha
Charlton - Lisbie (still awaiting that big move to Arsenal)
Chelsea - Johnson (absolute rubbish)
Palace - Routledge
Everton - Beattie
Fulham - Radzinski
Liverpool - Kewell
City - Mills
United - Van Nistelrooy
Boro - Viduka
Newcastle - Ameobi (touted for england carlton-cole style by sven)
Norwich - Huckerby
Portsmouth - Fuller (shit)
Southampton - Davenport
Tottenham - Atouba
WBA - Hoult
 

·
Premium Member
Joined
·
22,104 Posts
Faisal said:
Carrick Brown? LOL King has been Spurs best player this season.

You honestly think Carrick has been more valuable than him this season?
From the 1 match of Spurs I have watched this season Brown played well so I went for him, no other reason.
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
25,902 Posts
POTY:

Arsenal - Henry
Villa - Solano
Birmingham - M Taylor
Blackburn - Pedersen/Nelson
Charlton - El Karkouri
Chelsea - Makelele
Palace - Johnson
Everton - Cahill
Fulham - Malbranque
Liverpool - Carragher
City - Dunne
United - Keane
Boro - Downing
Newcastle - Boumsong (been an absolute rock)
Norwich - Huckerby
Pompey - De Zeeuw
Southampton - Crouchzinho
Tottenham - Robinson
WBA - Gera
 
1 - 20 of 32 Posts
Top