Xtratime Community banner

Formiranje na Balkanska Super Liga


  • Total voters
    17
1 - 18 of 18 Posts

·
Registered
Joined
·
2,860 Posts
Discussion Starter #1
Незнам дали некогаш е дискутирано на оваа тема на нашиот форум, но би сакал да го прочитам вашето мислење. Што мислите за формирањето на ваква Балканска Супер Лига која на почетокот би била составена од клубови од поранешните Ју републики?
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
972 Posts
JumboMkd said:
Незнам дали некогаш е дискутирано на оваа тема на нашиот форум, но би сакал да го прочитам вашето мислење. Што мислите за формирањето на ваква Балканска Супер Лига која на почетокот би била составена од клубови од поранешните Ју републики?

poranesnata Yu-liga bese silna imase natprevari kako Hajduk-Zvezda ili Dinamo-Partizan, Vardar-Zvezda:proud: i taka natamu vie natprevari vlecea na vreme mnogu ljuge i bese dobra konkurencija vo Evropa.
Deneska ni edna od bivsite republiki n moze da napraje nesto poveke vo Evropa na Vreme Zvezda beze najjaka na svetot a sega.......
Ne sakam da me razberete pogresno ne sakam da kazam deka ako se formira balkan-liga site ce bideme najjaki i cese kockame so Barceloni ili Chelsea. Ne sakam samo da kazam deka bilo koa pogolema Liga od nasata
e podobro sa fudbalot vo Zemjava.
oti fudbalot bez Navivaci ce izgube golem factor...
satoa ja bi podrzil ova idea ako postoji:thumbsup:
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
534 Posts
sa sal, sekoj pat koga se sboruva sa vakva liga vo drugite bivsi jugoslovenski drsavi, retko se sboruva sa makedonski ekipi.
mnogu slaba se vasi nasata liga.

od makedonija jas mislam deka samo vardar skopje i rabotnicki bi idele vo obzir:
vardar poradi tradicijata, rabotnicki poradi kvalitetot.
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
972 Posts
sebma said:
sa sal, sekoj pat koga se sboruva sa vakva liga vo drugite bivsi jugoslovenski drsavi, retko se sboruva sa makedonski ekipi.
mnogu slaba se vasi nasata liga.

od makedonija jas mislam deka samo vardar skopje i rabotnicki bi idele vo obzir:
vardar poradi tradicijata, rabotnicki poradi kvalitetot.
epa toa e realnosta:moan: ako me prasuvas mene ja bi samo Rabotnicki pustil da ode sato oti site ekipi sto se po losi placirani od prvoto mesto vo nasata liga ne gi biva sa nisto:mad:
ali satoa pa mislam deka Rabotniki moze da se mere so Hajduk Dinamo...itn
 
U

·
Guest
Joined
·
0 Posts
I voted yes, it will be good for the Skopje teams Rabotnicki,Vardar or Makedonija if they gett the chance. I think this could bring back the clubb soccer interest in Skopje.

But i dont think this should be only for X-Yug nations, i would have love to see Greek,Bulgar and Romanian teams as well. If it would be only for X-yug teams i would have voted no but if other nations are invited too then i,m very interested. I mean

Maribor,Zagreb,Hajduk,Partizan,Sarajevo are not better then Rabotnicki now days and a games beetwen Rabotnicki-Sarajevo or Rabotnicki-Hajduk will not keep better level then a game beetwen Rabotnicki-Makedonija so it will not develup our team and then i see it as pointless.

But if a reagional liga would look like this:

Partizan
Zvezda
Maribor
Domzale
Rabotnicki
Makedonija or Vardar
AEK
Olympiakos
Levski
CSKA
Sarejevo
Zeleznicar
Rapid Bukarest
Steaua Bukarest

Many games that would have develup our teams and thats why i would have seen ita as good idea. But there is many problems who most be solved. IF Rabotnicki and Makedonija play in a liga like this then there is a chance that Vardar will win the liga only cos MGP and Rabotnicki take part and vise versa. But not only Rabotnicki as exampel, i dont think any Balcan teams can play in 4 fronts (Domestic liga,Domestic Cup,Regional Liga, and Europ Cup) In the domestic cup Rabotnicki would have most likely playd with the Junior team but still 3 fronts are to much and i dont know how this could be solved. Rabotnicki is a teams with europ ambitions as well...

But this is not only a Rabotnicki problem, same problems will be for AEK; Partizan and every one else with so many games.
 
U

·
Guest
Joined
·
0 Posts
MKD Fanatico said:
epa toa e realnosta:moan: ako me prasuvas mene ja bi samo Rabotnicki pustil da ode sato oti site ekipi sto se po losi placirani od prvoto mesto vo nasata liga ne gi biva sa nisto:mad:
ali satoa pa mislam deka Rabotniki moze da se mere so Hajduk Dinamo...itn

Mislam deka e obratno, dobra sansa za Dinamo i Hajduk da se merat so Rabotnicki.

I ako imaat povejke pari od nas Hrvatskiot klubski rajting padna skros.
 

·
Expecto patronum!
Joined
·
13,563 Posts
jas galsav ZA predlogot no samo dokolku ligata bi izgledala kako Skandinavskata Royal liga. Da bide toa regionalno natprevaruvanje. Ednas cirav vo vesnik deka dokolku bi se ostvarila ovaa idea, togas ekipite so bi ucestvuvale vo Balkanskata liga bi bile oslobodeni od natprevarite vo domasnite prvenstva, nesto so voopsto ne mi se dopaga.
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
972 Posts
poleka ipoleka se prasuvam dali uopste bezbedno da se atprevaruvat bivsite yu-republiki u edna liga???
kako i so bese pred vojnata.
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
534 Posts
why should teams like olympiakos piräus and panathinaikos play in such a league?

ok, teams like steaua, red star, levski, etc. are better then the bad/midfield teams in greek, but their league is ok.

but i think that it would be a good idea with ex-yu + plus romanian and bulgarian teams.
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
139 Posts
I don't think this helps will the teams in our league at all. If only one or two teams get to play in this league it will be at most the top two who get to play in Europe anyway. The top teams will stay at the top and the worst will stay at their level. Our own league needs to get better.

Rabotnicki is already good, having them play against better competition does nothing to improve the quality of other teams like Napredok, Sileks and Stip.
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
28 Posts
National leagues 12 teams. 22 games for teams.

Balcanic league, with 16 teams. 30 games for teams.
The last 10 teams, play a play-off with the 10 winners of Balcanic League Level 2. 1 group for nation:

Albania
Kosovo
Makedonija
Srbja
Bosnija
Hrvatska
Slovenija
Greece
Crna Gora
Bulgaria

Cups: National Cup, and the winners, play with the 6 first of Balcanic League for the trophy.
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
2,767 Posts
The right play is a cup style mini tournament perhaps in the summer between select sides from the Balkan nations.

And I'm speaking of something more competitive than the friendly atmosphere of things like the Amsterdamn tournament.

Cup winners and league winners as Birrero said would be good from those nations he also mentioned.

A league replacing those national leagues will never happen. And as if we don't have enough problems with hooligans (at least in Greece), we don't need ethnic tensions rising (not to mention UEFA would never allow it).

The key is finding sponsors for this tournament and then making it feel more than a series of friendlies.
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
28 Posts
Icarus said:
And as if we don't have enough problems with hooligans (at least in Greece), we don't need ethnic tensions rising (not to mention UEFA would never allow it).
The hooligans is not only a problem of Greece.

In Spain it joins the fans of CE Sabadell, Barça, Athletic Bilbao, Llevant or Celta with those of the Madrid or Athletic Madrid. They would have serious problems. The police is for evite that.
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
27,119 Posts
I'm all for this but i dont want a league instead i would prefer a summer cup tourney where all the champions from each country play against each other to get a balkan champion.
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
2,767 Posts
Ambis said:
I'm all for this but i dont want a league instead i would prefer a summer cup tourney where all the champions from each country play against each other to get a balkan champion.
:thumbsup: :thumbsup:
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
1,929 Posts
Instead of this proposed league why not during the off-season arrange a friendly tournament with other teams in the Balkan Region. It would be nice if they did this because it will give us an idication/foresight of what the proposed league would be like. If the crowd numbers and interest is good, then its good for Balkan Football. It would also allow unknown talents to prove themselves against quality teams from our region.

I would definately like to see Rabotnicki verse some quality teams for our region.
 

·
Expecto patronum!
Joined
·
13,563 Posts
Ambis said:
I'm all for this but i dont want a league instead i would prefer a summer cup tourney where all the champions from each country play against each other to get a balkan champion.

Summer Cup? That wont be agood idea coz most of the best Balkan club play in Europe during the summer. IMO a copu of the Scandinavian Royal League will be the best option.
 
1 - 18 of 18 Posts
Top