Shatskikh? What exactly did he do to win it?
Running on the pitch like mad doesnt mean you're a footballer. Maybe a good athlete, but not a footballer. Rodrigo, a defender, while played less, scored almost as many as him.
Husyev? Yeah, this guy was prolly the most consistant.
Kleber, only got on form few months ago. Granted he had an injury at the start of the season and needed some time to get back, but to give him an award for playing well for like 2 months out the whole year?
In that case we could also nominate Correa, cant we?
Other than that i think Shovkovsky performed well, not up to his past high standard but still.
Finally, i would add Rebrov to the nomination list, although personally i wouldnt vote for him...